you probably want to define your requirements and then conduct your own bakeoff to see which solutions is the best for you and your organization. Did you ask Perforce for their input?
Bob Aiello, Technical Editor
We have a code review tool Atlassian Fisheye+Crucible already implemented, but we are using this with Perforce as our version control tool. Since Perforce has another code review tool "SWARM" we'd like to evaluate this tool. But need to know the benefits of using this tool over Crucible with fisheye.
SOme of the benefits I know is:
- efficient Pre-Commit code reviews
- No extra database to administrator
- Performance - Swarm executes transactions much faster than Crucible because Swarm is so tightly integrated with Perforce
- Ability to commit code from SWARm UI
I need to know from a core technical perspective if there is any other benefits.